Skip to content
Expert Corner

The Failure of the 28-Point Peace Proposal for Ukraine: How Diplomatic Efforts Continue to Falter

Europe felt a moment of respite on Monday, as the diplomatic emergency triggered by the presentation of a new 28-article proposal for achieving ceasefire appeared – briefly – to have been defused. A senior US official spoke of "significant advancement" after Ukraine-US talks in Geneva. On Monday night, the Kremlin made its retaliation: an extensive attack of missile and drone strikes on Kyiv.

The Rhythm of Diplomacy and Destruction

The succession of contrasting events captured the bleak nature of the current period. By day, diplomatic battles are conducted: hopeful statements are delivered from various governments. Immense energy is devoted on restraining particular approaches. By night, the Kremlin brutally reminds the world that, for them, war remains the main instrument for achieving "settlement".

Nocturnal Warfare

As military strikes progressed into the early hours of Tuesday, the present situation of Ukraine's defenselessness was laid bare. Ukraine is able to track missile launches from across the border, a capability enabled by timely intelligence. From vantage locations, defense planes that had been dispatched to engage hostile cruise missiles roared overhead – sophisticated military planes delivered to Ukraine by European allies.

Moments later, Kyiv's missile defense thundered: defensive missiles deployed against a incoming threat. This was a modern interception technology at work, probably delivered by partner states. Every deployment shakes the surroundings, causing tremors. The moment of terror quickly transforms into resigned acknowledgment: maybe the incoming missile won't cause damage this time, protecting urban areas from devastation and another blackout.

Continuous Dangers

Following this, a heavy machine gun opened up on a unmanned aircraft somewhere nearby, part of a defensive team – probably Western-made equipment. Regrettably, the bullets missed the hostile drone – it pressed on overhead toward its target.

Intermittently, this continued until dawn. Kyiv awoke to the morning news: seven people killed, devastation and utility failures in many homes as a result of the evening attack. As always, everyone still continued their routines – experiencing conflict. But those entire period demonstrated Ukraine's vital need on international aid – a dependence that regional partners are demonstrably unable to fill in the short term.

Failed Diplomacy

The 28-point plan from American leadership provoked deep reactions, debate and serious worry – and momentarily shifted focus from Ukraine's largest corruption scandal in years. Yet, we have witnessed similar scenarios, after earlier high-level meetings and multilateral gatherings.

Every new initiative from Washington adheres to the consistent cycle: a diplomatic cavalry charge against Ukraine, which Kyiv, with allied governments, succeeds in resisting. They contain the crisis but never actually achieve victory. This pattern will, certainly, persist.

Political Considerations

It is easy to blame specific actors of consistently pushing Russian terms. But that does not seem to be the entire situation. Washington works based on a premise understood by international relations experts: you cannot achieve through diplomacy what you have failed to defend militarily. The American government assumes that it is unrealistic to force Russia to relinquish the areas that it presently holds in Ukraine's occupied territories.

The problem is that while accepting these circumstances, Washington does nothing to discourage Russia, through words or deeds, from assuming that the situation will not evolve additionally in its advantage in the coming year.

Conflicting Perspectives

Therefore, Moscow is convinced that the clock favors them – that Ukraine and its supporters are coming close to fatigue. Their reason to sign a deal that does not give them the greatest potential benefit is almost completely absent. There may be many attempts to end hostilities, but they will continue as long as Russia's leader remains supremely confident in the conclusion.

On the contrary, Kyiv believes that Ukraine can still endure, progressively conceding civilians and areas but averting a total frontline collapse until conditions improve in its favour.

Current Realities

Realistically, there are no genuine requirements for a ceasefire. Now, individual motivations are entering the equation: political desires to negotiate peace and achieve global acclaim, and Kyiv's dual difficulties – on one hand, not to estrange crucial supporters, and on the other, to unite the population around the national cause against any plan Kyiv finds unacceptable, so that their attention does not shift toward homefront challenges. And although their objective will now be considerably more difficult after current events, it remains quite doubtful that this will change their overall approach.

These opposing factors are driving the talks.

Conclusion and Outlook

It took a just a single week to kill the suggested clauses of the most recent proposal. Forceful and unpredictable management of the matter by Washington, pushback by Ukraine and the other European countries, along with calming attempts of negotiators, and finally, recent disclosures, all served their function.

While new initiatives based on old ideas are forthcoming, Kyiv, London and other European capitals should arrive at a critical understanding: Ukraine and Europe will only be able to resist political attacks from Washington that are rooted in Kremlin requirements and reflect certain reluctance to change the course of events, if they stand together and strengthen their defence capabilities at a much faster pace. If they do, no combination of diplomatic or military actions will be able to break them. In the meantime, Ukraine's ability to repel nightly air assaults will, for the predictable period, mainly require ongoing international assistance.

JL
By

John Levine

James Hartwell is a seasoned content creator and researcher with over a decade of experience in simplifying complex topics for general audiences.

Expert Corner

Type to search articles.